Evaluating the Resale and Investment Value of Lab-Grown Diamonds

April 29, 2024

Introduction to Lab-Grown Diamonds

A new kind of diamond has entered a rapidly changing market: lab-grown diamonds. Instead of being extracted from the earth's crust, these diamonds are made in extremely controlled lab settings utilising advanced technical procedures that replicate the production of real diamonds. While chemically, physically, and optically identical to their mined counterparts, lab-grown diamonds have garnered significant attention due to their ethical and environmental advantages, as well as their potential as an investment asset.

Lab created diamonds have been around since the 1950s when scientists at General Electric managed to produce a small diamond crystal using a pressure high temperature method. It wasn't until the late 20th century that improvements in chemical vapour deposition techniques allowed for the mass production of higher quality lab grown diamonds.

At present, the lab-grown diamond market is expanding quickly, with a large range of lab-grown diamond rings, necklaces, and other exquisite jewellery available from well-known merchants like Blackwell Jewellers. The demand for these diamonds is expected to grow rapidly as consumer acceptance and knowledge rise.

Factors Affecting Resale Value of Lab-Grown Diamonds

The 4Cs (Cut, Colour, Clarity, and Carat Weight)

Like all real diamonds, the four Cs—cut, colour, clarity, and carat weight—have a significant impact on the resale value of lab-grown diamonds. These elements serve as the benchmarks for assessing diamond quality worldwide and are important in establishing a stone's beauty, uniqueness, and its value.

Cut: The cut of a diamond refers to its proportions, symmetry, and polish, which affect its ability to reflect light and create brilliance. A well-cut diamond with precise angles and facets will appear more dazzling and valuable than a poorly cut stone.
Colour: Diamonds are rated according to their colour; the best stones are colourless or nearly colourless. Since a colourless diamond can better reflect and refract light, giving it a brighter, more brilliant appearance, it is valued more highly when it is colourless.
Clarity: A diamond's clarity depends on whether inclusions(internal flaws) and blemishes (external flaws) are present or absent. The clarity grade and value of the diamond increase with the less amount of flaws and imperfections.
Carat Weight: A diamond's mass and size are determined by its carat weight. Larger diamonds are usually rarer and more costly, provided that the other three Cs—cut, colour, and clarity—are also of excellent quality.

The same 4Cs system is used to grade both lab-grown and mined diamonds, ensuring consistency and equality in the assessment of their worth and quality.

Certification and Grading Reports

To ensure transparency and validate the quality of lab-grown diamonds, it is crucial to obtain certification and grading reports from reputable, independent gemmological laboratories. These reports provide detailed information about the diamond's characteristics, including its cut, colour, clarity, and carat weight, as well as confirmation that it is a lab-grown stone.

Some of the most respected and widely recognized labs for diamond certification include:

The Gemmological Institute of America (GIA)
The International Gemmological Institute (IGI)

Certified lab-grown diamonds with comprehensive grading reports tend to have higher resale values compared to uncertified stones. These reports serve as a trusted reference for buyers and sellers, ensuring that the diamond's quality and value are accurately represented.

Brand Reputation and Pricing

The seller's pricing strategy and brand reputation can have a major effect on the resale value of lab-grown diamonds. Resell values are typically higher for well-known businesses with a track record in the diamond industry, like Blackwell Jewellers, because of their reputation for transparency, quality, and customer service.

Additionally, the seller's pricing technique may have an impact on how much others think the diamond is worth. Some companies can choose to use a premium pricing strategy, presenting their lab-grown diamonds as high-end products that demand greater costs. On the other hand, other vendors might take a more value-oriented and reasonably priced strategy, opening up lab-grown diamonds to a wider range of buyers.

While premium pricing can contribute to a higher perceived value and potential resale value, it's important to carefully evaluate the brand's reputation, quality assurance measures, and overall value proposition to ensure a fair and informed purchasing decision.

Investment Potential of Lab-Grown Diamonds

Supply and Demand Dynamics

The investment potential of lab-grown diamonds is largely driven by the interplay between supply and demand dynamics in the market. As consumer awareness and acceptance of lab-grown diamonds continue to grow, demand is expected to rise significantly. According to a report by Grand View Research, the global lab-grown diamond market is projected to reach $49.9 billion by 2030, with a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 21.5% from 2022 to 2030 [1].

However, the supply of lab-grown diamonds is also increasing rapidly as more producers enter the market and existing facilities expand their production capabilities. This influx of supply could potentially outpace demand, leading to a potential oversupply situation and downward pressure on prices.

Investors should carefully monitor supply and demand trends, as well as industry developments and technological advancements, to make informed decisions about the investment potential of lab-grown diamonds.

Comparison to Natural Diamond Investments

It's crucial to contrast lab-grown diamonds with their natural counterparts when thinking about investing in them. Natural diamonds have a history of price growth over time, making them a reliable asset for investments as well as a store of value.

When compared to natural diamonds of comparable quality, lab-grown diamonds are less expensive initially, which makes them an attractive investment option. Those with minimal capital in particular may find them more accessible due to their lower entrance point.

However, It's crucial to remember that lab-grown diamonds could not always appreciate in value in the same way that naturally occurring diamonds have in the past. There can be considerable differences between the two categories in terms of supply and demand dynamics as well as perceptions of exclusivity and uniqueness.

Investors should also consider the diversification benefits of investing in lab-grown diamonds. As a relatively new asset class, they may provide portfolio diversification and potential hedging opportunities against fluctuations in traditional investment markets.

Risks and Considerations

While lab-grown diamonds offer potential investment opportunities, investors should be aware of several risks and considerations:

Lack of Standardised Pricing: Unlike natural diamonds, which have established pricing benchmarks and indices (e.g., Rapaport Diamond Trade Price List), the pricing of lab-grown diamonds is currently less standardised, making it more challenging to accurately assess their value and potential for price appreciation.
Liquidity Challenges: The secondary market for lab-grown diamonds is still developing, which can lead to liquidity challenges when attempting to sell or trade these stones. Finding willing buyers at desired prices may be more difficult compared to natural diamonds.
Oversupply Risks: As mentioned earlier, the rapid increase in lab-grown diamond production could potentially lead to an oversupply situation, putting downward pressure on prices and impacting investment returns.
Regulatory and Ethical Considerations: While lab-grown diamonds are generally considered more ethical and environmentally friendly, investors should stay informed about any emerging regulations, industry standards, or ethical concerns that could impact the market dynamics.
Certification and Authentication: Ensuring proper certification and authentication from reputable gemmological laboratories is crucial to maintain the integrity and value of lab-grown diamond investments. Uncertified or improperly documented stones may face resale challenges and diminished value.

Thorough research, due diligence, and a well-diversified investment portfolio are recommended when considering lab-grown diamonds as an investment asset.

Tips for Buying and Selling Lab-Grown Diamonds

Whether you're looking to purchase a lab-grown diamond for personal use or investment purposes, or considering selling one, here are some tips to help you navigate the process:

Buying Lab-Grown Diamonds:

Work with Reputable Sellers: Purchase your lab-grown diamonds from reputable and accredited jewellers, such as Blackwell Jewellers, who can provide proper certification and documentation.
Insist on Certification: Ensure that the lab-grown diamond you're considering comes with a comprehensive grading report from a reputable gemmological laboratory like GIA or IGI This certification validates the diamond's quality and authenticity.
Understand the 4Cs: Educate yourself on the 4Cs (cut, colour, clarity, and carat weight) to make an informed decision about the quality and value of the diamond you're purchasing.
Consider Resale Value: If you plan to potentially resell the diamond in the future, choose a high-quality stone with excellent cut, colour, and clarity grades, as these factors significantly impact resale value.
Compare Prices: Shop around and compare prices from different sellers to ensure you're getting a fair deal. However, be wary of prices that seem too good to be true, as they may indicate quality or authenticity issues.

Selling Lab-Grown Diamonds:

Obtain Proper Documentation: Have the diamond's grading report and certification readily available to validate its quality and authenticity for potential buyers.
Choose the Right Marketplace: Consider reputable online marketplaces or consignment services that specialise in lab-grown diamonds to reach a broader audience of potential buyers.
Price Competitively: Research current market prices for similar lab-grown diamonds and price your stone competitively to attract buyers.
Highlight the Diamond's Qualities: Emphasise the diamond's positive attributes, such as its excellent cut, colour, clarity, and certification, to showcase its value and appeal.
Be Transparent: Disclose all relevant information about the diamond's origin, grading, and any potential flaws or treatments to maintain trust and credibility with buyers.

By following these tips, you can help ensure a smooth and successful buying or selling experience for your lab-grown diamonds.

Ethical and Environmental Impact

The advantages lab-grown diamonds have over traditionally mined diamonds in terms of ethics and the environment are major factors contributing to their rising appeal. A more ethical and environmentally friendly substitute, lab-grown diamonds solve a number of issues related to the mining sector.

Sustainable Production Methods

The procedure used to produce lab-grown diamonds is extremely efficient, controlled, and has little effect on the environment. The manufacturing of lab-grown diamonds has a much lower carbon footprint and uses fewer natural resources than mining, which can result in significant land disturbance, water pollution, and greenhouse gas emissions.

Additionally, lab-grown diamonds do not contribute to the social and humanitarian issues often associated with mining operations, such as labour exploitation, human rights violations, and conflict financing.

Reducing Mining's Environmental and Social Costs

The diamond mining industry has long been criticised for its negative environmental and social impacts, particularly in regions with weaker regulations and oversight. Mining activities have the potential to displace local communities, damage water supplies, and disturb ecosystems.

Lab-grown diamonds reduce these social and environmental costs by decreasing the demand for mined diamonds by providing an ethical substitute. The mining industry may face greater pressure to adopt more sustainable and responsible methods if more consumers choose lab-grown diamonds.

Ethical Sourcing and Corporate Responsibility

Many reputable lab-grown diamond companies prioritise ethical sourcing and corporate responsibility initiatives. They often implement stringent quality control measures, adhere to fair labour practices, and embrace transparency in their operations.

By choosing lab-grown diamonds from socially and environmentally conscious brands, consumers can support companies that align with their values and contribute to a more sustainable and equitable diamond industry.

The Future of Lab-Grown Diamonds

The lab-grown diamond industry is poised for significant growth and evolution in the coming years. As technology continues to advance and consumer awareness and acceptance increase, the future of lab-grown diamonds holds exciting possibilities.

Forecasting Future Market Growth and Consumer Adoption

The market for lab-grown diamonds is predicted to increase from just 3% in 2020 to 10% of the entire diamond market by 2030, per a report by Bain & Company [2]. The need for sustainable and conflict-free gemstones, growing affordability, and ethical concerns about diamonds mined are some of the reasons driving this explosive growth.

As more renowned jewellery retailers and brands accept lab grown diamonds, customer acceptance is expected to increase. This trend will likely be fuelled by marketing initiatives, greater accessibility, and changing customer tastes for ethical and environmentally friendly goods.

Technological Advancements Improving Quality and Costs

It is expected that continuous technological developments in the creation of lab-grown diamonds would further improve their quality and lower their price. High-pressure, high-temperature (HPHT) procedures and chemical vapour deposition (CVD) are two improved growing techniques that are making it possible to produce larger, better-quality diamonds with fewer imperfections and flaws.

Additionally, reduced manufacturing costs are making lab-grown diamonds more accessible to a larger range of consumers due to developments in automation, energy efficiency, and scalability of production facilities.

Potential Disruption to the Traditional Diamond Industry

The traditional diamond industry could be seriously impacted by the rise of lab-grown diamonds. These diamonds could overtake mined diamonds as they gain more traction and accessibility, potentially taking a bigger market share.

In order to stay competitive, traditional diamond mining businesses and retailers might need to change the way they do business and accept lab-grown diamonds. Some have already started to provide lines of lab-grown diamonds or are looking into joint ventures with producers of lab-grown diamonds.

Investing Opportunities as the Lab-Grown Market Evolves

The industry for lab-grown diamonds could offer special investment opportunities as it develops and grows. Investors may want to look into companies that produce, distribute, or sell lab-grown diamonds. They may also want to investigate possible opportunities in related technology and services.

However, It is essential that investors carry out extensive study, keep an eye on industry developments, and evaluate the possible benefits and drawbacks of investing in this developing sector.

Conclusion

The lab-grown diamond industry has come a long way since its inception, and its future looks increasingly promising. While the resale and investment value of lab-grown diamonds is still evolving, several factors contribute to their potential as an attractive and ethical alternative to mined diamonds.

The 4Cs (cut, colour, clarity, and carat weight), certification from reputable gemmological laboratories, and brand reputation play crucial roles in determining the resale value of lab-grown diamonds. Additionally, supply and demand dynamics, potential for price appreciation, and diversification benefits make lab-grown diamonds an intriguing investment opportunity.

However, investors and consumers alike should exercise caution and conduct thorough research, considering risks such as oversupply, liquidity challenges, and the lack of standardised pricing. Working with reputable sellers, insisting on proper certification, and understanding the diamond's qualities are essential when buying or selling lab-grown diamonds.

As technology continues to advance and consumer awareness grows, the lab-grown diamond industry is poised for significant growth and disruption. The ethical and environmental advantages of lab-grown diamonds, coupled with their potential affordability and accessibility, make them an attractive choice for socially conscious consumers.

While the future of lab-grown diamonds is promising, it's important to remember that personal preferences and individual circumstances should ultimately guide the decision to invest in or purchase these gemstones. Regardless of the choice, the diamond industry is evolving, and lab-grown diamonds are undoubtedly playing a pivotal role in shaping its future.

References:

Back to blog

Country/region